@FrancisStPierre's Forum Posts

Watersprite Lake Cabin - January 12th Meeting
Paul, I think that we should also explain that the 1 year threshold has been discussed many times at the BOD/exec and that it is in place to prevent a hostile takeover of the club at an AGM... not to...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
  It's not supposed to be keeping large amounts of funds in bank accounts or other investments for indefinite periods of time (and 30 years since the North Creek hut is getting pretty close to indefi...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
  A large number of members would like to see it proceed.   Hey Bill, what do you base your statement on? 
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Excellent example of railroading, Ed. Thank you for illustrating my point.
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Paul, the first step in finding a solution is to first agree on what is the problem. It appears that you agree with most (all?) of my points on what are the problems. Unfortunately, I'm quite certain...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Surprised to hear that the club compensated instructors... When I taught the multipitch course last summer with you Paul, I paid for my share of car pooling plus paid for my own gear used in the cours...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Paul,  do you mean that when we both attended the Nov WLC meeting and that Wilson repeatedly said that the project won't be stopped by just a few naysayers and that they would stick it back for a vote...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Hey Bill, how successful was the North Creek cabin process? Didn't it create a permanent division in the club? Also, in hindsight, how good of a location did we pick? I'd say that we should have learn...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
I know, Paul. You do a lot for the club. We have both witnessed first-hand how stubborn, arrogant and closed-minded the process for WSL has been. If that is the "positive" energy of the club, then I'm...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Paul, trip leaders are not machines... I personally don't feel motivated to lead trips for the BCMC at the moment. You asked me privately whether I would post more trips and I answered privately to yo...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Paul, while I attended the WSL Committee meetings I documented the discussions as a matter of record, which eventually resulted in Alena's website and the Project Proposal Document. So yes, I helped a...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Hmmm, if I may say... 48 votes in favour in a club of 700 people is hardly a landslide...  Meanwhile the club's trip list is looking rather dismal... where are the priorities? We all care about the cl...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
Hi Paul, A couple of points/corrections: I am not a formal member of the WSL Committee and only started attending its meeting in June as it is the only way to communicate with the Committee. So no nee...
Water sprite Hut Post-Mortem
I have stayed on the sidelines on this topic for some time, however I believe that this isn't the time to sweep the whole mess under the carpet, but instead we should take a closer look at what happen...
Climbing Insurance
Liability insurance: the club, its organizers, and members were insured in Canada and USA when I was last involved in negotiations for the club's insurance coverage (2014 or so, and may I point out th...
can't post on WSL cabin topic
I can read the posts but unlike all other topics, there is no handle for posting...
Climbing Insurance
Is the discussion about travel/medical insurance or liability insurance for club/organizer/participant?
Building Committee Minutes
Paul, you say "No one was made to feel uncomfortable for expressing a particular viewpoint". Look at your posts today where you are now dissecting in public and out of the blues what Stas, Lisa, and I...
Building Committee Minutes
Paul, perhaps you didn't understand me at the meeting as you aren't representing my comment accurately. I did not say that Watersprite will be inaccessible in winter, I said "if you vote yes tonight,...
Building Committee Minutes
Final report from Pierre Friele M.Sc., P. Geo. is attached as a PDF file (link at bottom).  Pierre, very generously offered to perform Pro Bono (meaning at no cost to the BCMC) a limited geomorphic h...
Building Committee Minutes
The geotechnical report is in and David asked me to please post it. In summary, sites near the lake are unsuitable for a cabin to meet avalanche safety norms; The site in Ed's earlier post and photos...
Darling Lake Trail Section 57 Application
Hey Chris, although I really like your Section 57 proposal and all the work you're doing for the Darling Lake trail, I would suggest that you should seek BOD approval before declaring war on BC Parks...
Who wants a cabin on the Coquihalla?
Checked out the West ridge of Llama on July 28 with Joanne and Siegfried (BCMC members). Could be a great spot for a hut:    - There is a tarn there with some water (needs filtering)     - Would mak...
Building Committee Minutes
I don't see any terrain suitable for mountain biking above Watersprite lake (for the common mortal, at least), so I question the value to mountain bikers. Makes sense to me to have the logging road ri...
Who wants a cabin on the Coquihalla?
Looks like there is some water at the base of Llamma's West ridge. Here's the picture from Ben a week ago (you must have a good telephoto!!). Looks promising. I'll go check it out on Tuesday.  Join me...